The effect of goal setting in asthma self-management education: A systematic review.
Yaoji Liao, Guozhen Gao, Yaqing Peng
PMID 31508456WHAT IT FOUND
Goal setting, delivered inside asthma education rather than alone, often improved adult quality of life and self-efficacy, while asthma control and healthcare use findings were mixed and child evidence weak.
Key findings
01Goal setting was not tested as a stand-alone treatment; it was included within broader asthma self-management programs.
02Across the included studies, 5 of 7 quality-of-life studies reported a significant intervention effect, and 2 studies reported improved self-efficacy, while asthma control findings were inconsistent.
03The evidence in children was limited: three child studies were included, one was underpowered, and one before-after school program had no control group.
STILL TO COME
How it was doneWhat they foundWhat it means for RNs
Read the rest of this summary
You get three full summaries a month, free, and we do not ask for a card. Search, the TL;DRs and your library stay unlimited either way.
What it does not show
Only nine studies were included, and some were small pilots or underpowered, so the review cannot settle questions about healthcare use, emotional health or children. Goal setting was combined with different education components and delivered by different providers in different settings, and the dose or session length was often unclear. Methodological quality was uneven: allocation concealment was often unclear, blinding was usually not possible, one study allocated groups by location with high bias, and only three studies used intention-to-treat analysis. Child evidence was weak: three child studies were included, one was underpowered, and one school-based study had no control group. One study did not report baseline age or gender, and some studies did not report session number or duration. The review was limited to English and Chinese articles because no translation resources were available.
Declared interests
The authors declared no conflicts of interest. The research was funded by the Science and technology department of Guangdong province.
The easy way to misread this
Do not conclude that goal setting alone improves asthma outcomes or reduces emergency visits. It was always part of broader asthma education, and healthcare-use findings were inconsistent, with no significant reduction in emergency department visits in the studies that assessed them.