Verbal feedback enhances motor learning during post-stroke gait retraining.
Nicole K Rendos, Laura Zajac-Cox, Rahul Thomas and 3 others
PMID 32942960WHAT IT FOUND
Adding a therapist's tailored verbal feedback to fast treadmill walking with electrical stimulation improved the affected leg's angle at toe-off 24 hours later in 9 stroke survivors.
Variable practice did not show clear learning gains.
Key findings
01Adding physical therapist verbal feedback to FastFES produced a greater angle of the affected leg at toe-off after training and at the retention test, and greater retention change scores than FastFES alone.
02The same therapist feedback showed only non-significant trends for better push-off after training and at the retention test.
03Variable practice did not show significant differences in push-off, trailing limb angle, or ankle angle change scores compared with FastFES, and because speed and stimulation timing were varied together, their separate effects cannot be separated.
STILL TO COME
How it was doneWhat they foundWhat it means for PTs
Read the rest of this summary
You get three full summaries a month, free, and we do not ask for a card. Search, the TL;DRs and your library stay unlimited either way.
What it does not show
Nine participants is a small sample, and only seven completed the variable practice block, so the study is preliminary and may not show effects that would appear in a larger group. The study tested one training session and lab biomechanical measures, not overground walking speed, Timed Up and Go, endurance, or falls risk. FastFES itself included fast treadmill walking and electrical stimulation to two muscle groups, so the feedback and variable practice conditions were not stand-alone treatments. The variable practice condition changed treadmill speed and stimulation timing at the same time, so the separate contribution of each cannot be identified. The physical therapist used non-scripted clinical judgment, so the exact words and demonstrations varied between participants. The study was not pre-registered as a clinical trial. Treadmill training speed was chosen for prolonged walking, which may not match short-distance overground speed in lower-functioning survivors. All participants could walk for 5 minutes at self-selected speed without an ankle foot orthosis, so results may not apply to non-ambulatory patients. For ankle angle at initial contact, the results section reports a more plantarflexed angle at retention compared with before training, while the discussion describes this change as restored at retention. A single session cannot establish cumulative learning over many treatments.
Declared interests
The supplied article text does not include a conflicts of interest or funding declaration. The publication types indicate NIH extramural and non-U.S. government research support.
The easy way to misread this
Do not conclude that verbal feedback by itself improves walking after stroke. It was tested only as an addition to fast treadmill walking with electrical stimulation, and the study measured lab gait angles after one session, not long-term walking ability.