Speech Recognition Outcomes After Cochlear Reimplantation Surgery.
Mariana Reis, Isabelle Boisvert, Valerie Looi and 1 others
PMID 28752810WHAT IT FOUND
44 of the 57 analysed reimplantation cases reached or exceeded their best previous speech recognition scores after surgery.
Poorer outcomes were linked to complications, incomplete electrode placement, cognitive decline, or facial nerve stimulation.
Key findings
0144 of the 57 analysed reimplantation cases had speech recognition after surgery similar to or better than the best score before surgery.
02Mean speech recognition score after reimplantation was 80.1%, compared with 46.4% last measured before reimplantation and 75.8% best before reimplantation.
03All nine patients with unsuccessful outcomes had additional issues, such as complicated surgery, incomplete insertion, cognitive or central processing issues, nonauditory sensations, or persistent otological condition.
STILL TO COME
How it was doneWhat they foundWhat it means for SLPs
Read the rest of this summary
You get three full summaries a month, free, and we do not ask for a card. Search, the TL;DRs and your library stay unlimited either way.
What it does not show
The study was retrospective and came from one centre, so it did not assign patients to treatment groups or compare them with adults who did not have reimplantation. Speech recognition scores before and after were not available for all reimplantation surgeries; the analysed set was 57 surgeries from 54 adults. The researchers used the best previous score and the highest after score, which may overestimate what a patient can achieve. For 22 surgeries, only one previous score was available, so it was used as both the best and last score. For 10 surgeries, only live voice scores were available, so the testing method was not uniform. The 10% rule for meaningful change was less conservative than the 20% rule used in some other work. There were too few patients in each reason for reimplantation to tell which reasons lead to poor outcomes.
Declared interests
The supplied text does not report funding or author conflict of interest declarations.
The easy way to misread this
Do not read the 80.1% average after reimplantation as a promise for every patient. The study selected the best previous score and the highest after score, so it may overestimate typical performance. It also included only adults who had scores available before and after surgery, and poor outcomes were concentrated in cases with complications, cognitive or central processing issues, or persistent ear problems.