Prospective, Single-blind, Randomized Controlled Trial to Evaluate the Effectiveness of a Digital Exercise Therapy Application Compared With Conventional Physical Therapy for the Treatment of Nonoperative Knee Conditions.
Marc P Gruner, Nathan Hogaboom, Ike Hasley and 5 others
PMID 34977534WHAT IT FOUND
For knee pain, an 8-week at-home app-based exercise program with videos and a band reduced pain interference and improved physical function more than standard outpatient physical therapy.
Adherence was similar: 2.6 versus 3.2 sessions per week.
Key findings
01Where higher pain interference scores mean worse pain, the program group's average 8-week change was -6.1 points and the standard physical therapy group's was -1.5 points.
02Where higher physical function scores mean greater function, the program group's average 8-week change was +6.0 points and the standard physical therapy group's was +0.8 points.
03Adherence was similar: the program group completed 2.6±1.1 sessions per week, and the physical therapy group self-reported 3.2±1.7 sessions per week.
STILL TO COME
How it was doneWhat they foundWhat it means for PTs
Read the rest of this summary
You get three full summaries a month, free, and we do not ask for a card. Search, the TL;DRs and your library stay unlimited either way.
What it does not show
Fifty of the sixty randomized participants were analyzed, and ten were lost to follow-up, including seven in the program group and three in the physical therapy group. Participants and outcomes were self-report, and participants were not blinded, so bias may have influenced the scores. The physical therapy group's actual treatment programs, home exercises, and progressions were not recorded or standardized, so the comparison is with variable usual care. The program group received the app, video sessions, and an exercise band, so the study cannot separate the effect of the app from the other components of the program. The sample came from one hospital system and included several knee diagnoses, so the result cannot be applied confidently to all knee conditions or other settings. Recruitment occurred during early pandemic, and some participants may have been unable to complete in-person physical therapy. Adherence was measured differently in the two groups: automatically by the app for the program group and by phone self-report for the physical therapy group.
Declared interests
The paper lists Limber Health Inc. as the app supplier, REDCap as the data capture tool, Fabrication Enterprises as the exercise band supplier, and The R Foundation for software, but it does not provide a funding or conflict-of-interest declaration.
The easy way to misread this
Do not conclude that the app alone caused the improvement or that it made patients more adherent. The program group used an app, video sessions, and an exercise band, and adherence was similar: 2.6 sessions per week in the program group and 3.2 sessions per week in the physical therapy group, with no reported difference.