PTOtherJournal of physical therapy science2019

Effects of the flexion-distraction technique and drop technique on straight leg raising angle and intervertebral disc height of patients with an intervertebral disc herniation.

Hyunju Oh, SeokJoo Choi, Sangyong Lee and 2 others

PMID 31528006

WHAT IT FOUND

Flexion-distraction, drop, and foramen magnum pump did not outperform spinal decompression for straight leg raising or disc height.

Both groups improved similarly after eight weeks, but both also received hot packs, interferential current, and ultrasound.

Key findings

01The between-group comparison found no significant difference in straight leg raising angle or intervertebral disc height.

02Within each group, straight leg raising angle and intervertebral disc height increased significantly after treatment. The experimental group's straight leg raising angle changed from 53.5 degrees to 72.0 degrees, and the control group's changed from 53.6 degrees to 71.7 degrees; disc height changed from 14.7 mm to 16.0 mm and from 15.3 mm to 16.3 mm.

03The experimental group also received a foramen magnum pump 10 times, and both groups received hot packs for 20 minutes, interferential current at 100 bps for 15 minutes, and ultrasound for 5 minutes three times per week for eight weeks, so the contribution of any single component cannot be separated.

STILL TO COME

How it was doneWhat they foundWhat it means for PTs

Read the rest of this summary

You get three full summaries a month, free, and we do not ask for a card. Search, the TL;DRs and your library stay unlimited either way.

Already have one?

What it does not show

Only 30 patients were studied, and the authors state the number was insufficient. All participants were women aged 20 to 60 with L5-S1 disc herniation symptoms, so the results may not apply to men, other ages, or other lumbar levels. The paper does not describe randomisation, allocation concealment, or blinding of patients and therapists. The experimental group received flexion-distraction, a foramen magnum pump, drop technique, hot packs, interferential current, and ultrasound, and the control group received spinal decompression plus the same hot packs, interferential current, and ultrasound, so no single component can be credited. The study did not control patients' daily activities and did not provide long-term follow-up. The reported outcomes were straight leg raising angle and disc height, not pain, function, or patient-reported benefit.

Declared interests

The methods name Zenith-Cox and WIZ medical devices, but no funding or conflict of interest declaration is included in the supplied text.

The easy way to misread this

Do not conclude that flexion-distraction and drop are proven better than spinal decompression. The between-group comparison was not significant, the experimental group also received a foramen magnum pump, and both groups received hot packs, interferential current, and ultrasound, so the named techniques cannot be isolated as the cause of improvement.

Read it on PubMed →