RNQualitativeMidwifery2022

The experience of fathers during the covid-19 UK maternity care restrictions.

Kathryn Andrews, Susan Ayers, Louise R Williams

PMID 35901609

WHAT IT FOUND

Fathers described UK maternity restrictions as isolating and disempowering.

They felt exclusion from scans and postnatal visits made early bonding harder. Lockdown and working from home also gave more family time, which some linked to better long-term bonding.

Key findings

01Most fathers disliked the maternity restrictions and described feeling helpless and useless.

02Fathers felt exclusion from antenatal scans and postnatal visits obstructed early father-baby bonding.

03Many fathers believed their exclusion left mothers alone to process information and thought it had a detrimental impact on maternal mental health.

STILL TO COME

How it was doneWhat they foundWhat it means for RNs

Read the rest of this summary

You get three full summaries a month, free, and we do not ask for a card. Search, the TL;DRs and your library stay unlimited either way.

Already have one?

What it does not show

The sample was voluntary and recruited through social media parent and father groups, so it may represent people who could access those groups. Only 20 fathers were included, and no non-cohabiting or non-biological fathers volunteered. All participants were married and cohabiting with the mother and were biological fathers of singleton pregnancies. Adopting parents, same-sex couples, fathers of babies in neonatal intensive care, fathers after pregnancy loss, and non-English speakers were excluded. Socio-economic data were not collected, and no South Asian, Black Caribbean, or Arab fathers volunteered. The sample size is small and generalisability is unknown. No member checking was done, so some participant statements may not have been understood accurately. The interviewer was a qualified midwife, and professional experience may have shaped the topic and methodology. The maternal impact was fathers' perception; mothers were not interviewed.

Declared interests

City, University of London provided financial support for data collection, and the authors declared no actual or potential conflicts of interest.

The easy way to misread this

Do not conclude that allowing partners back into maternity care will improve father-baby bonding or maternal mental health. This was a small qualitative study of fathers' experiences, not a controlled comparison, and the maternal effects were fathers' perceptions rather than measured outcomes.

Read it on PubMed →