Perceptual statistical learning over one week in child speech production.
Peter T Richtsmeier, Lisa Goffman
PMID 28662419WHAT IT FOUND
Hearing a sound sequence in more words and from more talkers did not improve overall speech accuracy across a week.
A small advantage appeared in the first production, then faded. This does not show that hearing more talkers and words alone fixes child speech errors.
Key findings
01Across all productions and both sessions, hearing a sequence in more words and from more talkers did not improve overall accuracy.
02Children were more accurate on the first production of session 1 for sequences heard in more words and from more talkers.
03The early advantage faded quickly: the first three productions showed only a marginal difference, and the overall effect was nonsignificant.
STILL TO COME
How it was doneWhat they foundWhat it means for SLPs
Read the rest of this summary
You get three full summaries a month, free, and we do not ask for a card. Search, the TL;DRs and your library stay unlimited either way.
What it does not show
Only 16 children were analyzed, and 22 were recruited, so the study is small and had dropouts and exclusions. The children were typically developing, native English speakers from one region, and scored within normal limits, so it does not show what happens in children with speech or language disorders. The children were generally above average in expressive language, vocabulary, receptive vocabulary and nonverbal skill, so results may not apply to children with lower language skills. The task used invented words and make-believe animals, not real words or the child's own speech errors. The high frequency condition combined more exposures, more words and more talkers, so the study cannot separate those components. The main comparison was null, and the positive finding came from looking at the first production and first three productions, so it may be a chance finding from multiple comparisons. The follow-up was only one week, so it cannot show whether any effect would last longer or affect real speech development.
The easy way to misread this
Do not conclude that hearing more talkers and more words improves child speech production over a week. The main analysis was null, and the high frequency condition combined more exposures, more words and more talkers, so their separate contributions cannot be known.