RNCohortJournal of the American Medical Directors Association2021

Coronavirus Disease 2019 in French Residential Care Facilities: A Nationwide Study.

Joël Belmin, Scarlett Georges, Florian Franke and 9 others

PMID 33865795

WHAT IT FOUND

During France's first wave, residential care facilities had far fewer COVID-19 cases and deaths per 100 beds than nursing homes: 1.10 vs 9.97 cases and 0.07 vs 1.29 deaths.

This does not prove why.

Key findings

01310 of 2288 residential care facilities (14%) and 3110 of 7688 nursing homes (40%) reported at least one confirmed case (P<.001).

02Total COVID-19 cases were reported at 1.10 per 100 beds in residential care facilities and 9.97 per 100 beds in nursing homes.

03COVID-19 deaths were 0.07 per 100 beds in residential care facilities and 1.29 per 100 beds in nursing homes, and case fatality was 6.49% versus 12.93%.

STILL TO COME

How it was doneWhat they foundWhat it means for RNs

Read the rest of this summary

You get three full summaries a month, free, and we do not ask for a card. Search, the TL;DRs and your library stay unlimited either way.

Already have one?

What it does not show

The study used maximum bed capacity as the denominator, not actual occupancy, so rates may be imprecise. Cases may have been underreported or underdiagnosed, especially in residential care facilities, although the authors considered this unlikely. Testing practices may have differed between facility types, but facility-wide testing was not performed during the first wave. Possible cases were included on clinical presentation without laboratory confirmation in facilities with at least one confirmed case, which may have overestimated cases. The supplied text does not report adjustment for resident health, dependence, dementia, staff contacts, or facility organization, so the study cannot establish why rates differed. The French case definition differed from WHO and CDC definitions, but it was applied to both facility types.

The easy way to misread this

Do not conclude that residential care facilities are inherently safer or that moving residents there lowers infection risk. The study reports observed facility-level case and death rates, not tested interventions, and the differences may relate to resident health, dependence, dementia, staff contacts, or reporting.

Read it on PubMed →