PTRCTJournal of rehabilitation medicine2022

Comparison of Quadriceps and Hamstring Muscle Strength after Exercises with and without Blood Flow Restriction following Anterior Cruciate Ligament Surgery: A Randomized Controlled Trial.

Rafael Francisco Vieira de Melo, William Ricardo Komatsu, Mellissa Sales de Freitas and 2 others

PMID 36190389

WHAT IT FOUND

After ACL surgery, low-load knee exercises with blood flow restriction showed greater strength gains and better knee pain and function scores than higher-load exercises without restriction.

Key findings

01The low-load blood-flow-restriction group showed greater strength gains in the injured leg, with knee flexor strength greater from the second post-surgical period onward and quadriceps strength greater after 12 weeks.

02Self-reported knee pain and function favoured the low-load blood-flow-restriction group, with significant differences on KOOS pain after 4 weeks and on KOOS symptoms, daily activity, and quality of life at later time points.

03No adverse effects occurred, but initial discomfort, fatigue, and thigh hyperaemia were reported during low-load blood-flow-restriction training and improved after occlusion removal.

STILL TO COME

How it was doneWhat they foundWhat it means for PTs

Read the rest of this summary

You get three full summaries a month, free, and we do not ask for a card. Search, the TL;DRs and your library stay unlimited either way.

Already have one?

What it does not show

Participants could not be blinded because the intervention used visible pneumatic cuffs, which may affect effort during strength tests and self-reported pain or function scores. The study was small and single-site, with 28 patients recruited and Table I characterizing 12 patients per group, so it may not apply to other settings, grafts, ages, or rehabilitation stages. The blood-flow-restriction group also trained at a lower load than the control group, using 30% of one repetition maximum while the control group used 70% without occlusion, so the design cannot separate the effect of occlusion from the effect of lower load. The supplied text does not fully clarify how many participants were analysed at each time point or how dropouts were handled, although the flowchart is referenced. The intervention required individualized total occlusion pressure measured with a Doppler device and a specific low-load repetition scheme, so results may not transfer to use without those safety and protocol elements. Strength was measured isometrically with a handheld dynamometer, not with the isokinetic method used in some other studies, so direct comparison with other protocols may be limited.

The easy way to misread this

Do not conclude that blood flow restriction alone caused the benefit. The blood-flow-restriction group also trained at 30% of one repetition maximum, while the control group trained at 70% without occlusion, so the design cannot separate the effect of the cuff from the effect of lower load.

Read it on PubMed →


The study

Participants
28 patients were recruited, 14 in each group; Table I characterizes 12 in each group.
Certainty of evidence
Moderate

More in orthopaedic

Browse

Cite

Rafael Francisco Vieira de Melo, William Ricardo Komatsu, Mellissa Sales de Freitas, et al. Comparison of Quadriceps and Hamstring Muscle Strength after Exercises with and without Blood Flow Restriction following Anterior Cruciate Ligament Surgery: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Journal of rehabilitation medicine. 2022.

Read the original