RNRCTJournal of the American Association of Nurse Practitioners2016

Comparing mothers' postpartum concerns in two clinical trials 18 years apart.

Jean Hannan, Dorothy Brooten, JoAnne M Youngblut and 1 others

PMID 27273192

WHAT IT FOUND

Infant feeding was the top infant concern in both samples, but mothers' own recorded worries differed: 2015 first-time mothers noted fatigue, no help and difficulty, while 1997 high-risk mothers noted body changes, birth control and health problems.

Key findings

01Infant feeding was the top infant concern in both samples.

02Mothers' postpartum concerns about themselves differed by trial: 2015 mothers focused on not having help, fatigue and finding things hard, while 1997 mothers focused on body changes, birth control, breastfeeding and maternal health problems.

03Situational concerns differed: financial problems appeared in both, but 2015 mothers were heavily concerned about lacking health insurance, lacking a physician for mother and newborn, and transportation problems.

STILL TO COME

How it was doneWhat they foundWhat it means for RNs

Read the rest of this summary

You get three full summaries a month, free, and we do not ask for a card. Search, the TL;DRs and your library stay unlimited either way.

Already have one?

What it does not show

The analysis included only 58 and 63 mothers from the intervention groups, not all mothers in the trials or all postpartum women. The two trials studied different populations: mostly African American mothers with high-risk pregnancies in 1997 and mostly Hispanic first-time mothers with limited health-care access in 2015. The mothers received different forms of advanced practice nurse care, including a postpartum home visit in 1997 but phone and text follow-up in 2015. The health-care financing and Medicaid access context changed between the two trials, so differences in concerns may reflect those changes rather than time alone. The outcome was content of interaction logs, coded as individual concerns, not a validated measure of how common each concern was among mothers. The paper does not report a control-group comparison of concerns because usual care groups had no routine recording of mothers' concerns.

The easy way to misread this

Do not read the different concern counts as proof that postpartum concerns changed because of the 18-year gap. The two groups were different populations, received different nurse follow-up, and the analysis used only concerns recorded in intervention logs, not all mothers.

Read it on PubMed →