OtherJMIR rehabilitation and assistive technologies2021

A Virtual Smash Room for Venting Frustration or Just Having Fun: Participatory Design of Virtual Environments in Digitally Reinforced Cancer Rehabilitation.

Johanna Persson, Douglas Clifford, Mattias Wallergård and 1 others

PMID 34617913

WHAT IT FOUND

Patients found the VR smash room enjoyable and relaxing, but 23 of 101 reported headache or dizziness.

Grip difficulties and hardware issues were common. This was a design test, not a trial of efficacy for venting frustration.

Key findings

01Participants rated the experience as enjoyable and attention-holding, with mean scores of 4.52 and 4.44 on a 5-point scale.

02Headache or dizziness was the most reported symptom, affecting 23 of 101 participants (22.8%).

03Seven participants reported difficulty gripping the virtual tools, and four reported hardware problems such as controller failure or blurred vision.

STILL TO COME

How it was doneWhat they found

Read the rest of this summary

You get three full summaries a month, free, and we do not ask for a card. Search, the TL;DRs and your library stay unlimited either way.

Already have one?

What it does not show

This was a formative design study, not a randomized controlled trial, so it cannot determine if the VR application effectively helps patients cope with frustration or improves rehabilitation outcomes. Symptoms like headache and dizziness were only measured after the VR session; there were no baseline measures, so it is unclear if these symptoms were caused by the VR or pre-existing. Participants had no specific instructions and varied widely in how long they used the application and which rooms they chose, making it difficult to standardize the experience. No demographic or clinical data was collected, so it is unknown how age, gender, or specific cancer treatments might have influenced the results. The study was conducted in a group rehabilitation setting, which may not reflect how patients would use such technology privately or in a clinic. The VR hardware used (HTC Vive) is an older consumer model with known issues like the 'screen door effect' and lower resolution, which may have contributed to discomfort and usability problems.

Declared interests

The paper does not explicitly state a funding source or conflict of interest declaration in the provided text. The authors mention a Swedish research program exploring digital support in cancer rehabilitation.

The easy way to misread this

Do not interpret the high enjoyment scores as evidence that this VR application effectively treats anxiety or helps patients vent frustration. The study was a design test with no control group, no baseline symptom measures, and no clinical outcomes, so it only shows that patients liked the experience and found it usable despite some physical side effects.

Read it on PubMed →


The study

Participants
101
Certainty of evidence
Low

Browse

    Cite

    Johanna Persson, Douglas Clifford, Mattias Wallergård, et al. A Virtual Smash Room for Venting Frustration or Just Having Fun: Participatory Design of Virtual Environments in Digitally Reinforced Cancer Rehabilitation. JMIR rehabilitation and assistive technologies. 2021.

    Read the original