A systematic review of theory-informed strategies used in interventions fostering family genetic risk communication.
Jingsong Zhao, Yue Guan, Colleen M McBride
PMID 35304074WHAT IT FOUND
Most interventions did not improve family communication about inherited genetic risk.
Only two randomized trials showed effects, using a coaching booklet or mobile app outside routine genetic counseling. The evidence is limited, mostly cancer-focused, and not generalizable.
Key findings
01Only two included randomized trials reported significant intervention effects.
02Eight of the nine included studies focused on cancer syndromes.
03All nine included studies used strategies linked to a theory, but only five named the theory.
STILL TO COME
How it was doneWhat they foundWhat it means for RNs
Read the rest of this summary
You get three full summaries a month, free, and we do not ask for a card. Search, the TL;DRs and your library stay unlimited either way.
What it does not show
Only nine studies met the review's criteria, so the evidence base is small. The review included only English, peer-reviewed published studies, so interventions reported in other languages or grey literature were not analyzed. Most included studies focused on hereditary cancer syndromes, not on other inherited conditions. Most participants were women, and the studies were often conducted in specialty genetic counseling settings, so they may not apply to men, other conditions, or routine clinical settings. The two trials with effects involved asymptomatic individuals and were conducted outside genetic counseling contexts, so they may not reflect typical counseling care. Many studies did not assess implementation factors such as fidelity, feasibility, or sustainability, and no studies linked acceptability to theory-based mechanisms. Acceptability was defined differently across studies, and high acceptability was not associated with significant intervention effects.
Declared interests
The supplied metadata indicates NIH extramural research support; the provided article text does not include an author conflict-of-interest statement.
The easy way to misread this
Do not conclude that family genetic risk communication interventions generally work. Only two randomized trials reported effects, and most included studies focused on cancer syndromes in specialty genetic counseling settings, so the results do not show that routine education materials or nurse counseling will improve relatives' awareness or testing.